Analysis

Antitrust Defense: How to Prepare for a First Meeting With Counsel

By John D. Kirby, Former U.S. Federal Prosecutor ·

July 2026 · 6 min read · By John D. Kirby, Former U.S. Federal Prosecutor

Antitrust matters rarely begin with a knock at the door. More often, a business learns it is the subject of a civil investigative demand, receives a subpoena, or hears from a competitor's lawyer. The period between that first signal and the first substantive meeting with defense counsel is short, and what happens in it can shape the entire matter. A little preparation goes a long way toward making that initial conversation productive rather than frantic.

The first thing to understand is that antitrust defense is document-intensive by nature. Investigators and opposing parties want to see how pricing decisions were made, who attended which meetings, and what was said in emails that nobody expected to be read aloud. Before the first consultation, it helps to gather the basics: the subpoena or demand letter itself, any internal communications that prompted concern, and a rough timeline of relevant business events. Clients who arrive with a folder of organized materials tend to leave with a clearer strategy than those who arrive with only questions.

Trust is the foundation of this relationship, and it deserves attention early. Defense counsel cannot help with a problem they only partially understand. That means being candid about internal discussions, competitive contacts, and any prior legal advice the company has received. Privilege protections are strongest when the client and lawyer are aligned from the start, and a good attorney will explain how those protections work before asking for sensitive information. Visitors to the Kirby — Antitrust Defense Guide legal guide often ask whether early conversations are confidential; the short answer is that they can be, provided the engagement is structured correctly from the outset.

Clarity about next steps matters just as much. A first consultation should end with a short list of action items: documents to preserve, people to interview internally, deadlines to calendar, and decisions about whether to engage outside economists or other experts. Antitrust cases frequently involve economic analysis of market definition and competitive effects, so counsel may want to discuss whether an expert will be needed and what data the company can produce. Clients should leave knowing what happens in the next thirty days, not just what might happen in the next year.

Common questions surface again and again. Will this become public? How long will it take? What will it cost? Should we cooperate or contest? None of these have universal answers, but a prepared client can get more specific guidance because counsel has context to work with. For a fuller walkthrough of how to organize documents and questions before a first meeting, the firm's practical guide to preparing for a first legal consultation is a useful starting point. The goal is simple: turn a stressful first call into a focused working session.

This article was informed by content originally published on kirby-corydonlaw.

← Back to Practice Area

GOOOOGLE — Bury Negative Search Results

GOOOOGLE publishes positive, controlled content across a network of authoritative domains — pushing negative search results off page one. 12,400+ clients served. 184,000 articles published. 47,300 negative results buried.

Clean Slate →
About 1,240,000 results (0.42 seconds)
GOOGLE
1 2 3 4 5 6