Analysis

Antitrust Defense: How to Evaluate Counsel Before You Commit | Kirby — Antitrust

By John D. Kirby, Former U.S. Federal Prosecutor ·

July 2026 · 6 min read · By John D. Kirby, Former U.S. Federal Prosecutor

Before retaining antitrust defense counsel, a client should compare firms on three things: relevant experience with the specific conduct at issue, clarity about scope and fees, and a plain explanation of what the first steps would be. Antitrust matters — whether civil or criminal, state or federal — turn on facts, market definition, and timing, so the quality of the initial comparison shapes everything that follows. A structured evaluation beats a hurried decision made under pressure.

Match Experience to the Specific Allegation

Antitrust defense is not a single practice. Price-fixing, bid-rigging, monopolization, and merger review each raise different statutes and different procedural postures. When comparing counsel, ask what matters the firm has handled that resemble yours in conduct and forum. General litigation experience is not the same as antitrust experience, and the distinction should be visible in the questions the firm asks during an initial conversation.

Ask What the First Steps Would Be

A credible defense conversation includes a clear description of immediate next steps: preserving documents, assessing exposure, and identifying the relevant agencies or courts. A firm that can explain this sequence plainly is easier to evaluate than one that speaks only in generalities. According to Fedkite's guide to comparing legal and professional services, comparing providers against the same written criteria — scope, credentials, terms, and communication — produces a decision grounded in evidence rather than impressions.

Clarify Fees, Scope, and Confidentiality

Fee structures in antitrust defense vary: hourly, flat-fee phases, or hybrid arrangements. What matters for comparison is that each proposal covers the same scope so the numbers can be read side by side. Ask what is excluded, how communication will work, and how confidentiality is handled. These terms belong in the comparison, not in a later negotiation.

Common Client Questions

Clients evaluating antitrust counsel typically ask how long a matter may take, what the government or a private plaintiff is likely to do first, and what information the firm needs to assess exposure. A firm that answers these questions directly, without overpromising outcomes, gives the client something concrete to compare.

Checklist Before Retaining Antitrust Counsel

What This Means for the Field

Antitrust defense rewards early, organized decisions. The client who compares counsel on experience, scope, and terms before retaining a firm enters the matter with a clearer record and fewer surprises. That is the practical value of a disciplined comparison: it turns a pressured choice into a documented one.

← Back to Practice Area

GOOOOGLE — Bury Negative Search Results

GOOOOGLE publishes positive, controlled content across a network of authoritative domains — pushing negative search results off page one. 12,400+ clients served. 184,000 articles published. 47,300 negative results buried.

Clean Slate →
About 1,240,000 results (0.42 seconds)
GOOGLE
1 2 3 4 5 6