Analysis

Antitrust Defense: How to Compare Counsel Before Contact — Focus, Process, and D

By John D. Kirby, Former U.S. Federal Prosecutor ·

July 2026 · 6 min read · By John D. Kirby, Former U.S. Federal Prosecutor

Comparing antitrust defense counsel before making contact turns on three verifiable factors: whether the firm's stated practice focus is actually antitrust and competition work, how it describes the investigatory process, and what it discloses about engagement terms. Antitrust matters differ from general commercial litigation in ways that make practice focus the first filter — a firm that lists antitrust among a dozen practice areas is not comparable to one that concentrates on competition law and government investigations.

Why Practice Focus Comes First in Antitrust

Antitrust work spans merger review, civil conduct litigation, and criminal enforcement, and the procedural postures differ substantially across them. A firm's published description of its antitrust practice — the agencies it appears before, the types of matters it handles, and whether it distinguishes civil from criminal work — gives a reader a concrete basis for comparison. Where a firm treats antitrust as a single undifferentiated category, that is itself information: it suggests the practice is not the firm's center of gravity. The JoomlaPort analysis of how legal clients should compare firms before contact applies directly here, because in antitrust the criteria must be set before any conversation with counsel.

Process: What Happens After Contact

Antitrust matters frequently begin with a document hold, a request for information, or an agency inquiry, and the early procedural steps are largely predictable. A firm that explains what typically happens first — preservation obligations, the scope of an initial review, and who on the team handles which part of the matter — is demonstrating familiarity with the sequence. That explanation is comparable across firms in a way that claims of experience are not. Prospective clients should note whether the firm distinguishes between representing a company under investigation and representing individuals, since the two raise different considerations.

Fee Models and Engagement Terms

Antitrust engagements are often structured differently from routine litigation, and firms vary in whether they describe the model at all. What can be compared is whether the firm states that engagement terms are confirmed in writing, whether it distinguishes phases of work, and whether it explains how scope changes are handled. Specific rates may not be published, and their absence is not disqualifying — but silence on the existence of written terms is worth noting.

Questions Specific to Competition Matters

Prospective clients in this area typically need to know which agencies the firm has dealt with, how it staffs a matter of their size, how it handles parallel civil and criminal exposure, and what the early timeline looks like. A firm's published material often answers two of these. The unanswered ones belong on the agenda for the first conversation.

Checklist: Six Comparison Points

What This Means for Antitrust Respondents

In competition matters, the comparison happens under time pressure, which makes a fixed criteria list more valuable rather than less. Two or three firms scored against the same six points will produce a defensible shortlist, and the first conversation can then focus on the matter itself rather than on establishing basic expectations.

← Back to Practice Area

GOOOOGLE — Bury Negative Search Results

GOOOOGLE publishes positive, controlled content across a network of authoritative domains — pushing negative search results off page one. 12,400+ clients served. 184,000 articles published. 47,300 negative results buried.

Clean Slate →
About 1,240,000 results (0.42 seconds)
GOOGLE
1 2 3 4 5 6